Do you have to steal anything to be charged with misapplication of fiduciary property?
No. Penal Code §32.45 is committed by dealing with property contrary to the agreement you hold it under, or contrary to a law governing its custody, in a way that involves a substantial risk of loss. Recklessness is enough, intent to steal is not required, and the owner does not have to lose anything at all. That is why the charge reaches people who never thought of themselves as taking money.
- The mental state can be intentional, knowing or reckless. Reckless is the one that catches people.
- Misapply means dealing with property contrary to the agreement you hold it under, or contrary to a law prescribing its custody or disposition.
- The conduct must involve substantial risk of loss. Actual loss is not an element.
- Fiduciary is defined broadly and expressly includes an attorney in fact or agent under a durable power of attorney.
- The grade runs by value, from a Class C misdemeanor under $100 to a first degree felony at $300,000 or more.
- An offence against an elderly individual moves up one category, except at the very top of the ladder.
- In Medicaid cases the Attorney General can prosecute alongside the local prosecutor, with that prosecutor consent.
What the offence requires
Subsection (b) of Penal Code §32.45 states the whole offence in one sentence. A person commits it if he intentionally, knowingly or recklessly misapplies property he holds as a fiduciary, or property of a financial institution, in a manner that involves substantial risk of loss to the owner or to the person for whose benefit the property is held.
Three things in that sentence do nearly all the work, and none of them is theft.
Recklessly is in the statute
Most property offences in chapter 32 require intent. This one does not. Recklessness is sufficient, which means a person can commit it without ever deciding to take anything, and without believing they were doing anything wrong, if they were aware of and consciously disregarded a substantial and unjustifiable risk.
In practice that is how a large share of these cases begin. Money held for one purpose is used for another with the intention of putting it back. Funds belonging to several people are kept in one account and drawn on without tracking whose money is whose. A business short of cash this month covers payroll from a deposit it holds for a client. None of that is a decision to steal. All of it can satisfy subsection (b).
Misapply is defined by the agreement, not by honesty
Subsection (a)(2) defines misapply as dealing with property contrary to an agreement under which the fiduciary holds it, or contrary to a law prescribing the custody or disposition of the property. The reference point is the agreement or the statute, not whether the conduct was well intentioned or whether the person believed they had authority in a general sense.
This is why the documents decide these cases. A trust instrument, a contract, a management agreement, an escrow instruction or a statute defining how particular funds must be held sets the line, and conduct is measured against that line. An arrangement everyone was comfortable with in practice does not amend the written terms.
Substantial risk of loss, not actual loss
The offence requires that the misapplication involved substantial risk of loss. It does not require that anyone lost money. A person who moved funds improperly and replaced them in full before anyone noticed has not avoided the elements, because the exposure existed while the money was gone.
Repayment is still worth a great deal, but it belongs to a different part of the case. It affects the value figure, the negotiating position and the sentence. It does not make out a defence to the conduct.
Who counts as a fiduciary
Subsection (a)(1) defines fiduciary broadly. It includes a trustee, guardian, administrator, executor, conservator and receiver. It includes an attorney in fact or agent appointed under a durable power of attorney under Subtitle P, Title 2 of the Estates Code. It includes any other person acting in a fiduciary capacity, with a narrow carve out for commercial bailees except in certain motor fuel sales arrangements. And it includes an officer, manager, employee or agent carrying on fiduciary functions on behalf of a fiduciary.
The power of attorney branch deserves particular attention, because it reaches ordinary family situations. An adult child managing a parent finances under a durable power of attorney is a fiduciary for this section. Using the parent money in a way the instrument does not authorise, even for things the family considers reasonable and even where the parent would have agreed, is dealing with property contrary to the agreement under which it is held. These allegations frequently arrive through a sibling rather than through a bank.
The last branch matters in business cases. An employee carrying out fiduciary functions for an employer who is itself a fiduciary is covered, so the charge is not confined to the person whose name is on the trust document.
The value ladder
Subsection (c) grades the offence entirely by the value of the property misapplied. It is a Class C misdemeanor under $100, a Class B at $100 or more but less than $750, a Class A at $750 or more but less than $2,500, a state jail felony at $2,500 or more but less than $30,000, a third degree felony at $30,000 or more but less than $150,000, a second degree felony at $150,000 or more but less than $300,000, and a first degree felony at $300,000 or more.
A first degree felony is the same punishment range as aggravated robbery. A bookkeeping pattern that nobody characterised as theft can therefore sit in the most serious band in the Penal Code, purely on the arithmetic, which is why the valuation is the most valuable thing in the file to contest. What was actually held in a fiduciary capacity, over what period, and whether sums were double counted as they moved between accounts are questions that routinely move a case down a rung or several.
The elderly enhancement
Subsection (d) raises an offence graded under subsections (c)(1) to (c)(6) to the next higher category where it is shown at trial that the offence was committed against an elderly individual as defined by Penal Code §22.04. The top rung is already at the ceiling and does not move.
Given how often these allegations involve a power of attorney over an older relative finances, the enhancement applies in a large share of family cases, and it is what turns a state jail felony into a third degree one.
Medicaid cases and who prosecutes
Subsection (e) gives the Attorney General concurrent jurisdiction with the local county or district attorney, with that prosecutor consent, to prosecute an offence under this section involving the state Medicaid programme. A case that looks like a local matter can therefore be handled by a state level unit with different resources and a different approach to resolution.
Where these cases are contested
The agreement is the first place to look, because the offence is defined by it. What the instrument actually authorised, whether the conduct fell inside it, and whether the terms were varied by the parties in a way the law recognises are threshold questions, and they are legal questions as much as factual ones.
Whether the person was a fiduciary at all is the second. Not every person who holds someone else money occupies a fiduciary capacity, and the statute excludes commercial bailees outside the fuel sales context. A debtor who fails to pay is not automatically a fiduciary who misapplied.
The mental state is the third. Recklessness requires conscious disregard of a substantial and unjustifiable risk, which is a real standard rather than a synonym for carelessness. Poor records, an unsophisticated operator and an absence of any concealment point away from it. So does conduct that continued openly for years in full view of the people now complaining.
Frequently asked questions
Is misapplication of fiduciary property the same as theft?
No. Theft requires unlawful appropriation with intent to deprive the owner. Penal Code §32.45 requires only that property held as a fiduciary was dealt with contrary to the agreement or a law governing it, in a way involving substantial risk of loss, and recklessness is enough. A person can commit it without any intention of keeping anything.
Can I be charged if I paid all the money back?
Yes. The element is substantial risk of loss, not actual loss, so the offence is complete even where the funds were restored before anyone noticed. Repayment is still important, because it bears on the value figure, the sentencing range and what resolution is realistic, but it is not a defence to the conduct.
Does using a parent money under a power of attorney count?
It can. Subsection (a)(1) of Penal Code §32.45 expressly includes an attorney in fact or agent appointed under a durable power of attorney in the definition of fiduciary. Spending the parent money in a way the instrument does not authorise is dealing with the property contrary to the agreement under which it is held, and these cases are often reported by another family member.
How much does it take to make this a felony?
Property valued at $2,500 or more makes it a state jail felony under subsection (c)(4). It becomes a third degree felony at $30,000, a second degree felony at $150,000, and a first degree felony at $300,000 or more. An offence against an elderly individual moves up one category unless it is already at the top.
Who is an elderly individual for the enhancement?
The section borrows the definition in Penal Code §22.04. Subsection (d) of section 32.45 raises offences graded under subsections (c)(1) to (c)(6) to the next higher category where it is shown at trial that the offence was committed against an elderly individual.
Can the Attorney General prosecute this instead of the county?
In Medicaid cases, yes, alongside the local prosecutor. Subsection (e) gives the Attorney General concurrent jurisdiction with the consenting county or district attorney to prosecute an offence under this section that involves the state Medicaid programme.
If an accusation has been made
Do not move money between the accounts in question, do not reconstruct records from memory, and do not write an explanation to the complaining party. Preserve the governing document, whether that is a trust, a contract, an escrow instruction or a power of attorney, because the case is measured against it. For the wider picture, start with the types of fraud charges in Texas.
The law this page describes, at the source.
This page is general legal information about Texas law, not legal advice about your case. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, so confirm the current rule with a licensed Texas criminal defense attorney about your specific facts. Request a free, confidential case review.